Few cheap bits of kit divide people quite like a mosquito band. Read the 100 most recent reviews of the Anbar pack and the split is stark: 60 are five-star, 24 are one-star, and the two groups are describing what feels like a completely different product. That 4.2-star average across 1,326 ratings sounds settled until you see how far apart the camps actually are.

The five-star camp reports holidays with no bites at all, in places that have ruined them before. The one-star camp reports getting bitten directly next to the band, sometimes with one strapped to every limb. There isn't much middle ground, and that disagreement is the whole story here. At £7.95 for 14 bands the stakes are low, but "will they stop me getting eaten alive" is a fair question to want answered before you pack them. Here's what the reviews actually tell you.

The same product, two completely different holidays

Start with the two reviews that bookend this listing. One buyer, posting after ten days in Orlando, wrote: "for the first time ever, after 10 days in Orlando Florida I came back with ZERO bites!! I had one on each wrist and one on each ankle." They now won't go abroad without them.

Then there's a one-star review titled "these dont work", written from a sun lounger mid-holiday: "bought for holiday in kos. im still in kos writing this, wearing the bands in fact i am wearing one on each limb. I have been here 4 days and have a total on 17 bites and counting." Same pack, same four-bands-on strategy, polar opposite outcome.

This pattern repeats right through the 100 reviews. JANE STABLES returned from Tunisia, where her kids had previously needed medical treatment for bites, and reported "not a bite in sight". Damien Babington was bitten-free in Uganda. On the other side, Colette M. wore one on each wrist and ankle and "got the worst bites I have ever had", bad enough to need antibiotic cream from a doctor. Sarah wore them on all limbs and was "bitten over 20+ times in Majorca", noting that similar bands had worked for her in Cuba and Rhodes. The bands clearly do something for some people. They equally clearly do nothing for others, and there's no obvious reason in the reviews why.

Where they seem to land best: midges and kids

If there's a pattern in the positive reviews, two use cases come up more than the rest. The first is Scottish biting insects. Mrs Evans gave five stars specifically for that: "Pleasant smell which is not overpowering. Work well to deter midges in Scotland." Goldilocks arch was using them "for middies and cleggs" (midges and clegs, the local name for horseflies) and reported "so far so good". Mrs Blakeman's review was simply titled "Trip to Scotland" with "no bites easy to wear". For a summer in the Highlands, where midges turn an evening pitch into a misery, that's worth knowing.

The second is children. Parents like them because kids will actually keep them on, which is half the battle. Mrs Valerie Ferguson said her children "loved them as they looked just like 'cool' bracelets". Another reviewer noted kids "love wearing them as there bright and easy to use". Gary Lees used his in Tunisia and they "became hair bands after", and Mr Robert Moore confirmed the packet itself suggests using them as hairbands. MR C J NAWOJ's family wore them "around their socks or tied them in their laces". A repellent a six-year-old wants to wear beats a stronger one that ends up in the bottom of the bag.

The smartest way people use them: as a backup, not the plan

The most useful tip buried in the reviews isn't from the fans or the critics, it's from the people who treat the bands as one layer rather than the whole defence. A handful of reviewers describe pairing the bands with a normal repellent spray, and they're some of the more measured write-ups on the page.

Vicky was clear about it: "Worked great and kept mosquitos away! Only used it in combination with a normal skin mosquito repellent (not on its own)." Mrs l davis used spray "as well for added protection" across ten days in Tanzania. gary c. gave a four-star, eyes-open verdict: "They seemed to help but nothing beats real repellent spray which I also used after being bitten." Even one of the more generous reviewers, Colette Robbie, framed them as "a great extra layer of protection" that "might not completely replace stronger repellents in heavy mosquito conditions".

That's the realistic way to read this product. As your only barrier in a mosquito-heavy spot, the reviews suggest you're gambling. As a DEET-free top-up that the kids will keep on, on the pram, or around your ankles while you eat outside, far more people are happy. Go in expecting a supplement and you're much less likely to be the person writing an angry review from a sun lounger.

About that '250 hours' claim

Anbar markets the bands as offering "up to 250 hours of protection", which works out to more than ten days of continuous wear. That's the manufacturer's figure, and the reviews don't back it up. Real-world duration runs a lot shorter.

Mrs.p.masters, a fan giving four stars, said they "last for around 4 days even waring in the sea and swimming pools". gary c. reckoned "around 24 hours" before he resprayed his with proper repellent. Mike S. complained the "smell on them only lasted 2 days". The bands work by slowly releasing scented oils, so once that smell fades, so does any effect, and humidity, heat and swimming all speed that up. The 14-pack actually makes sense in that light: the listing pitches it as enough "to use a new one anytime you need to refresh protection", which is the sensible way to handle a band that doesn't last a fortnight. Treat each one as good for a few days, not 250 hours, and rotate to a fresh band rather than expecting one to see out a long trip. Storage matters too: Dorothy E White still rated them five stars but titled her review "They need to be stored in a cool place", and davec praised the "packaging to keep them fresh".

What's actually in them (and what the listing won't tell you)

The Amazon listing keeps it vague: "high-quality, natural ingredients", DEET-free, non-toxic, and described as gentle enough for sensitive skin and safe for small toddlers. If you're avoiding DEET for young children or your own skin, that's the main draw, and it's the reason a lot of parents pick these over a chemical spray. Just note the listing's own wording is "safe for" toddlers, not any kind of formal certification, so use your judgement with very young children.

For the actual blend, the listing stays quiet, but one detailed reviewer fills the gap. Mr Robert Moore, who tested them in detail, reckons the pleasant scent "is probably down to the all natural mix of equal parts citronella oil, peppermint oil, lemongrass oil and eucalyptus oil". That's his read rather than a published spec, so treat it as an informed guess from a buyer, not a guaranteed ingredients list. It does line up with the smell most reviewers describe, and those four oils are the usual suspects in natural repellents.

The bands themselves are stretchy, waterproof and properly one-size-fits-all. Mr Robert Moore confirmed "they expand quite easily to fit adult wrists or ankles", and the colour mix gets near-universal praise, with flowerjen happy to "mix and match with holiday outfits".

The smell divides people as much as the results

Worth flagging before you buy, because it's the second-biggest theme after effectiveness: the scent is strong, and not everyone gets on with it. Plenty love it. Mrs Evans called it "pleasant... not overpowering", davec noted a "nice smell that has lasted", and one reviewer said the bands "smell great".

But it's potent enough to be a problem for some. Sally Creasey, a two-star reviewer, found "the smell is over powering, it gave me a headache". Emma Stobbart warned that they "smell really strong" and to bear that in mind "if you're going to wear them in the evening". Mr Steven Mckane split the difference, calling it a "strong repellent smell but not too over powering", and attached one to his baby's pram. If you're sensitive to strong scents, this is the kind of product to try on one wrist before you commit to wearing four at dinner.

Quality gripes: bands that split before you've left home

Beyond whether they repel anything, a handful of reviewers had a more basic complaint: the bands physically falling apart. It's not the dominant theme, but it comes up enough to mention. Ally C left one star: "all the bands were either already broken or fell apart as soon as I put them on." Mike S. ordered two packs and found "half split has soon has you put them on". Bully, sitting on the fence at three stars, said they "break easy".

With 14 bands in a pack, a couple of duds isn't a disaster, and most reviewers don't mention any breakage at all. Mighty Mutha said "the bands fit very well" and planned to buy more. But if you're relying on a specific number for a big family trip, it's worth checking them over when they arrive rather than the night before you fly.

The case for buying them, and the case against

This isn't a product to oversell, because the reviews won't let you. The fairest summary: at £7.95 for 14, the Anbar bands are a low-cost, DEET-free layer that works well for a good chunk of buyers and does nothing for a real minority. The 24 one-star reviews out of 100 are not a rounding error, and the people writing them aren't doing anything wrong, several were wearing a band on every limb.

Buy them if you want a kid-friendly, spray-free option for the bag, if you're heading somewhere with midges or clegs rather than tropical mosquitoes, or if you'll use them as a top-up alongside a proper repellent. They're great value in those roles, and the colours and hairband trick make them an easy sell to children. Be cautious if you're relying on them as your sole defence in a heavy-mosquito destination, or if strong scents give you a headache. And whatever you do, pack a backup spray, because the happiest reviewers here are the ones who never bet the holiday on a wristband alone.

Anbar Mosquito Repellent Bracelet Bands (14 Pack)

DEET-free, all-natural, waterproof mosquito bands in a mix of bright colours. A cheap, kid-friendly layer of bite protection for holidays, midge country and the garden, best used alongside a spray.